The Web Realm
     Marc Chadwick's Weblog
 Local: Home About Contact
Wishlists: Books DVDs Thinkgeek 
Syndicate: RSS RSD Atom

 Mobile Phones vs Personal Devices
Mobile Phones 

I remember years ago saying, "I want my phone to be a phone. Nothing more than a phone. Nothing less." I suppose to a degree that's true, except I am not buying a phone anymore. I am purchasing a Personal Device. A device upon which I will rely for many aspects of my life. I will use this device for my telephone, yes. But I will use it for SMS, MMS, a camera in a pinch. I will use it for a calendar, for a phone book, for a note pad. I will use it to get directions to wherever I'm going, to figure out where I want to be going. I might even use the right one for some music.

In realizing this I have been forced to re-evaluate my choices and opinions regarding my purchases. I have to break out of the paradigm of a phone just being a phone and start to accept how much more than that it can be. Then I have to determine how much of that I want. In doing so, I have begun to understand more of the hype around new phones and features. There are so many and varied different things for these devices. Those that I listed above are the ones that matter to me. And to others? The office suite. The fact that they can do presentations from their phone. The fact that they have a home theater in their pocket. Things like that.

I have to begin to think of my Smart Phone differently. I have to think of what I want it to be. Design my own in my mind, and define why.

I will start by defining my priorities better.

- First and foremost, my phone is a phone. I need it to be good at being a phone - quality in sound is a must. Speaker phone is a must for me because, well, I use it. The ability to use Bluetooth hands-free devices is critical for my success. Battery life is important to me - I need to be able to actually use my phone regularly throughout a day and not run out of battery before it ends.

- My Personal Device is my communications hub when I am not at home or at a computer. Quality SMS, MMS, and Email support is critical.

- My Personal Device will be my organizer. Long gone are the days when a Palm Pilot was a new thing. My personal device has this functionality in it and it works well. It must be able to synchronize with my computer(s) in both directions. This means at a minimum it must have Mac support. It is preferable that this support be built-in with iSync, but I will accept it if there is a high quality third-party application that integrates with iSync. Either way, I will only accept the use of iSync. Linux support would be neat but is not required.

I must be able to sync my calendars and my address book. It would be good to be able to synchronize my to do list, too. I must be able to sync my address book. I must be able to take notes for later review quickly and easily.

- My Personal Device must be customizable; it needs to support a variety of third party applications and, possibly, to allow me to write my own. This includes apps like Google Maps, which I do rely on regularly, or PuTTY.

Knowing that these are my basic requirements, let's talk about interface. Qwerty keyboards are a requirement for me, so that eliminates a few Smart Phones right there. This leaves a two basic interfaces: devices that are driven by the dial pad and devices driven by a touch screen.

For me, devices with a dial pad are fantastic and provide a strong degree of one-handedness (is that a word?). It means that if for some reason I must send an SMS or look up directions while driving, I can. It'll be with some difficulty, and I strongly recommend against such an act as it is unsafe and in some states I'm sure illegal, but it's a whole lot easier than doing it with a two-handed device. Additionally, there are many devices with dial pads that can be manipulated to reveal a qwerty keyboard - the best of both worlds.

A device with a touch screen used to be boring and annoying for me. I hated them. Then came the iPhone. They re-thought the entire interface. Still, though, the lack of a physical keyboard is too much for me. Enter HTC. HTC's Touch interface is beautiful. While it is a tad lacking, I hope that they continue to run with it in the Kaiser and make even more improvements. When they do, I suspect that this would be a very usable interface and comparable to the iPhone. It might not be quite as pretty, but it will be every bit as usable. And, I admit, it's a whole lot prettier than the basic interface.

I think the question in my mind is where the technology is going. It seems like the world wants touch screens, so perhaps my next device should follow that trend. But I just can't quite give up the mechanical keyboard, even if it's just the qwerty one.

For me, if I can program a certain missing feature into my Nokia E70 I'm going to stick with it for a while. Tempting though it may be to switch, none of the upcoming phones I've seen support both frequencies T-Mobile has earmarked for 3G use in the states. That's a downer for me.

Let's see what comes next.

 Comments:

Leave a comment

 

February 2008
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
          1 2
3 4 5 6 7 8 9
10 11 12 13 14 15 16
17 18 19 20 21 22 23
24 25 26 27 28 29  


Recent Entries
# links for 2008-02-10
# Biofuels Do More Harm Than Good
# del.icio.us
# That'll do it
# Under Construction
# Revamp
# GooSync
# Trusting Google
# Play AACs on your TiVo with TiVo Desktop from a Mac
# My Once and Future Cloud
Flickr Photostream
www.flickr.com
Categories
Apple
Aquarium
Banking
Blog Stuff
Bookmarks
Books
Boston
Comedy
Comics
Development
Drama
Entertainment
For the Mac
Hacks
Hardware
In The News
Internet
Linux
Mobile Phones
Movies
Music
Open Source
OS X
Politics
Red Sox
Science
Security
Software
Sports
Stuff 'n Junk
Sysadmin Stuff
Technology
Television
Testing
Thoughts
UNIX
Vermont
Virii
Windows
Tags
blog  cloud  development  bookmarks  google  code  email  global warming  gmail  google calendar  news  organization  politics  science  study  symbian  tags  test  web 2.0 
Archives
February 2008
January 2008
December 2007
November 2007
October 2007
September 2007
August 2007
July 2007
March 2007
February 2007
January 2007
December 2006
November 2006
September 2006
August 2006
July 2006
June 2006
May 2006
April 2006
March 2006
February 2006
January 2006
December 2005
November 2005
October 2005
September 2005
August 2005
December 2004
November 2004
October 2004
September 2004
August 2004
July 2004
June 2004
May 2004
April 2004
March 2004
Guest Posts
Blog for America
Boston Metroblogs
Links
802 Online
Blog for America
Boston Metroblogs
Dream Theater Info Network
Dr. Mosh
Engadget
Gizmodo
Lukwam
Mac OS X Hints
The Register
SAGE
Skadz
Slashdot
Kevin Smith
Powered by Movable Type Publishing Platform
This blog is licensed under a Creative Commons License.